heating FAQ

Should I Replace My Water Heater Before It Fails?

Short Answer: Replacing a water heater before it fails is wise as it ensures continuous hot water, reduces the risk of potential water damage, lowers energy bills with better efficiency, and allows for a smooth transition to a modern, eco-friendly unit without rush.

Lindemann Hero Image

At Lindemann, we often get asked a lot of questions about chimneys, fireplaces, and HVAC systems since that’s what we do best. A question that pops up often is, “Should I replace my water heater before it stops working?” Let’s look at the answer to this question and learn more about your water heater in the process.

Understanding How Long Water Heaters Last

Water heaters are super important in our homes. They give us hot water whenever we need it, which is awesome especially in cold weather. Usually, a regular water heater can work well for about 10 to 15 years, but some special ones called tankless water heaters can go up to 20 years. However, many things like the type of water you have and how often you check and fix your heater can affect how long it lasts.

Why Changing It Early is a Good Idea

Choosing to replace your water heater before it conks out is like staying one step ahead in a game. It’s about avoiding the inconvenience that comes with sudden cold showers, especially when you least expect it. Plus, this proactive decision can lead to saving money on bills, enjoying better features, and even doing a little good for our planet, making it a win-win situation for everyone.

  • No Surprise Cold Showers: If your water heater stops working suddenly, it can be really annoying. Changing it before it breaks down means you won’t have to deal with unexpected cold showers.
  • Saving Money: Old water heaters can make your bills go up because they don’t work as well as they used to. Newer models are made to use less energy, which can help save some money on bills.
  • Helping the Planet: When you use less energy, you’re also being nice to the environment. It’s a cool way to help reduce pollution.
  • Cool New Features: New water heaters have some neat features like being able to set the temperature just the way you like it, which can also help save energy.
  • Increasing Your Home’s Value: If you plan on selling your house someday, having a new water heater can be a good selling point. It’s a smart investment.

Checking Your Current Water Heater

Keeping tabs on your current water heater’s performance is a smart way to avoid any unpleasant surprises like an unexpected cold shower. Regular check-ups can help spot signs that it’s time for a replacement before you run into any major issues. Understanding what to look for when inspecting your water heater can save you time and money in the long run, ensuring you make a timely decision on whether or not a new water heater is in order.

  • Water Temperature: If you notice that the water temperature is inconsistent, or it takes a long time to get hot, it could be a sign that your water heater is struggling.
  • Unusual Noises: Hearing strange noises like rumbling, popping, or banging from your water heater is a sign that there might be a buildup of sediment at the bottom of the tank, which can affect its efficiency.
  • Water Color: Rusty or muddy water coming from your faucets when using hot water can indicate corrosion inside the water heater tank.
  • Leaks: Water pooling around the base of your water heater is a clear sign of a leak, which can lead to potential failure and damage to your home.
  • Age of the Heater: Knowing the age of your water heater is crucial. If it’s approaching or has surpassed the typical lifespan of 10 to 15 years, it’s likely time to consider a replacement.
  • Frequency of Repairs: If you find yourself frequently calling in for repairs, it might be more cost-effective to replace the unit rather than continue to fix it.
  • Energy Bills: A sudden spike in your energy bills could indicate that your water heater is working overtime to provide the hot water you need, showing its inefficiency.

Getting a New Water Heater

Embarking on the journey of acquiring a new water heater is a progressive step towards enhanced comfort and efficiency. Consulting with seasoned professionals like us at Lindemann can provide invaluable insights into the various types of water heaters available, helping you choose a model that aligns with your household needs and preferences.

Whether it’s a traditional tank water heater or a modern tankless version, each comes with its own set of benefits. Our team can guide you through the features, energy efficiency ratings, and capacity considerations to ensure you make a well-informed choice. Moreover, professional installation is key to ensuring your new water heater operates optimally from the get-go.

Thinking About the Cost

The upfront cost of a new water heater can indeed pose a significant expenditure. However, it’s essential to view it as a long-term investment that can yield numerous benefits. A more efficient water heater can contribute to lowering your monthly utility bills by consuming less energy to heat water.

Additionally, newer models tend to require fewer repairs, further reducing your maintenance expenses over time. To alleviate the immediate financial burden, various financing options and manufacturer rebates may be available, making the investment more manageable.


Taking the proactive step of replacing your water heater before it fails is an embodiment of foresight that guarantees uninterrupted comfort and financial savings in the long run. The transition to a new, efficient water heater is not merely about averting the inconvenience of a sudden breakdown, but about elevating the overall functionality and eco-friendliness of your household utilities.

At Lindemann, we stand ready to assist you in this worthwhile endeavor, ensuring a smooth and beneficial transition to a new water heater that serves you reliably for many years to come.